Best Ice Fishing Spoons for Crappie: Top Picks for a Successful Bite

When ice fishing for crappie, the right spoon lure can mean the difference between a cold, quiet day and a steady stringer. This guide highlights five top-performing ice fishing spoons that attract crappie, perch, and other panfish. Each pick targets different conditions, so you can choose the best lure for clear water, stained water, daylight, or night trips. The buyers below are separated by clear “best for” guidance to help you decide quickly.

Quick buying snapshot:

Product	Best For	Key Feature
Dovesun 15PCS Glow Spoons Kit	All-around panfish and walleye	Built-in rattle and glow-in-the-dark paint
Northland Tackle Thumper Spoon (Brass)	Clear water with flash	Flutter blade plus micro flicker
Northland Tackle Tungsten Slim Spoon	Deep bite, fast sinking	Dense tungsten; thin profile
Northland Tackle Glass Buck-Shot Spoon	Vivid color and sound	Glass-like translucent body and rattle
Reaction Tackle Tungsten Jigging Spoons	Deep water vertical jigging	Dense tungsten with mirror flash

Dovesun 15PCS Glow Ice Spoons Kit

Check Price on Amazon

The Dovesun kit combines multiple rattling spoons designed to attract crappie and other panfish from a distance. The built-in two steel balls create a low-frequency rattle that mimics live prey and can draw distant schools toward the lure. This makes it well-suited for anglers who fish in deeper ponds or in windy conditions where visibility and sound travel are crucial.

Best for: anglers who want a versatile, all-in-one starter set with audible attraction and glow-in-the-dark visibility. It’s especially effective for night fishing or low-light days when crappie are receptive to flashing silhouettes.

Limitation: only three spoon types in the set actually rattle, so readers should not expect universal rattling across all spoons.

Northland Tackle Ice Fishing Thumper Spoon

Check Price on Amazon

The Thumper Spoon uses a thin brass profile with a micro flicker blade to deliver a fluttering fall and lively action. Its design mimics a wounded baitfish, triggering aggressive strikes from walleye, crappie, bluegill, and more in both clear and stained water. The added flutter blade increases flash and vibration, helping you trigger bites in challenging winter setups.

Best for: anglers working colder, clearer water where extra flash on the descent can lure cautious crappie into biting.

Caution: brass spoons can bend if snagged; handle with care when fishing around structure.

Northland Tackle Tungsten Slim Spoon

<img alt="Tungsten Slim Spoon

Check Price on Amazon

This slim, ultra-dense spoon provides rapid sinking and a strong, reflective flash to draw bites in deep water. The tungsten body is 70% denser than lead, allowing quick descent and staying in the strike zone longer. It pairs well with natural baitfish patterns for clear water and bright, glow designs for murkier conditions.

Best for: deep-water crappie and walleye where sinking speed and visibility matter. Choose this if you fish deeper zones or use sonar to target suspended fish.

Limitation: higher material cost due to tungsten; may be pricier than traditional metal spoons.

Northland Tackle Thumper Spoon (Purple Wonder)

The Purple Wonder version of the Thumper Spoon emphasizes flash and finesse with a purple color and brass flutter profile. It delivers the same reliable fluttering action on the fall and uses a micro flicker blade to increase light and vibration in murky or overcast conditions. This presentation is effective for drawing aggressive strikes from a broad range of species.

Best for: anglers who want a bright, high-contrast option that stands out in stained water or low-light days.

Limitation: color choice may not perform the same in ultra-clear, bright light conditions as more natural patterns.

Northland Tackle Glass Buck-Shot Spoon

Check Price on Amazon

The Glass Buck-Shot Spoon uses a translucent “Glass” look with a high-pitched glass rattle and bright resin coating to call in walleye, perch, bluegill, and crappie. It combines a lifelike baitfish appearance with a loud, unique sound that can be effective in water with cover or when fish are skittish. Treble hooks and a resin finish reduce chipping and keep color bright longer.

Best for: anglers who want a distinctive visual and audio lure. Use in clearer waters where the glassy appearance can trigger curiosity and bites.

Limitation: translucent finish can wear with heavy use and may require occasional touch-ups to maintain visibility.

Reaction Tackle Tungsten Jigging Spoons

Check Price on Amazon

Reaction Tackle’s jigging spoons are designed for vertical fishing in deep water. The dense tungsten body sinks quickly, flashes brilliantly, and triggers reaction strikes from bass, walleye, crappie, and pike. The mirror-polished finish enhances light reflection at depth, improving bite detection in low-visibility conditions.

Best for: anglers who vertical jig in deep water or use sonar to locate suspended fish. The fast descent helps reach the strike zone fast on pressured waters.

Limitation: designed for deep-water use; may not be as effective on shallow ice unless actively jigged.

Buying Guide: Key Considerations For Ice Fishing Spoons

• Water clarity: Choose brighter or glow-in-the-dark spoons for murky or dark days, and natural or translucent finishes for clear water.
• Sinking rate: Tungsten spoons sink faster, which is advantageous for deep-water bites or aggressive schools; brass spoons are slower and better for shallow, reactive fishing.
• Sound and flash: Rattle chambers and flutter blades increase attraction; use multiple lures to compare effectiveness in a single trip.
• Durability: Look for robust finishes (resin-coated, chip-resistant) if you fish around rocks or structure.
• Hook quality: Treble hooks offer high hookup potential but may be harder to manage; consider replacing hooks if necessary for your target species.
• Color and pattern: Match patterns to local forage; bright or contrast colors often outperform natural patterns in stained water.
• Size and weight: Align lure size with the typical forage size in your area; heavier spoons sink quicker and hold vertical depth better.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Q: What color works best for crappie on ice? A: Bright or glow colors often perform well in low light or stained water; natural patterns can work in clear water.
• Q: Should I use one spoon or a mix on the ice? A: A mix allows you to compare performance under different conditions and can catch more fish in variable days.
• Q: How deep should spoons be fished for crappie? A: Start near the structure and adjust depth to where crappie are actively feeding; use electronics to locate suspended fish.
• Q: Are tungsten spoons better than brass for crappie? A: Tungsten sinks faster and provides greater sensitivity, which can improve bite detection in deeper water.
• Q: Do spoons need to be “jigged” or can they be retrieved steadily? A: Both methods work; vary speed and pauses to trigger bites in different conditions.